Monday, February 2, 2015

Our College Choice: Uncovering a Familial- and Culturally-Based College Decision-Making Process

by Michelle M. Espino, Assistant Professor at the University of Maryland, College Park

My research interests regarding institutional cultures as well as community contexts that affect and inform educational achievement, outcomes, and experiences along the P-20 pipeline for racial/ethnic minorities are based on uncovering and addressing my own journey as a Chicana, middle class, first-generation college student who is the first in my extended families to obtain a doctorate.  My work focuses on countering deficit-based models about Latina/o students and their families because I believe that various forms of community cultural wealth as well as limited forms of the cultural capital valued by the dominant culture enhanced my journey through higher education (Espino, 2014; Yosso, 2005, 2006).

During my childhood, my parents and extended kin shared wisdom around the kitchen table that moved beyond formal schooling and centered on our family’s cultural assets.  These stories helped me understand my role within the family, and what was possible and appropriate within familial and cultural contexts (Espino, 2007).  My family’s stories and consejos (advice) imparted upon me an intergenerational investment in my educational success and personal development.  I learned that being bién educada meant that my morals and values were foundational rather than supplemental to my formal education (Auerbach, 2006; Valdes, 1996).  Personally and professionally I honor the imaginative aspect of agency embedded within the stories shared through my work as a scholar, as well as my lived experience as a Chicana, a daughter, and an aunt.  A year ago, the intersections of these identities unearthed tensions between lived experience and scholarly discourse that have profoundly changed my perspective on college access and choice.

Last spring, I was on a conference call with my parents.  My nephew, whom they had raised, was ready to make a decision about which university he planned to attend: one of my alma maters or the university where I work as a faculty member.  I was nervous.  The universities had been pared down from eight institutions that we had researched together based on location, prestige, and his career interests—some of these schools had already made their choice about my nephew, much to our disappointment.  As a first-generation college student, my own college choice seemed a bit happenstance and I believed that providing an organized and methodical approach would prove less arduous for my nephew and our family.  Because I was the only one in my family with a college degree and because I had research and professional expertise in the field of higher education, my parents expected that their investment in my formal education and their (in)direct influence on my college aspirations and trajectory (Ceja, 2004) would eventually lead to educational opportunities and success for my nephew.  As Alvarez (2010) noted, Latina/o families often direct questions and concerns to their older children or other family members who have attended college: it was my turn to give back.

True to what I understood as a higher education scholar, I intended to provide my nephew with a range of options with a resulting college choice that he would make independent of me and his family that reflected his hard work and effort.  I wanted to believe that the research I had read about college choice would accurately reflect my nephew’s decision-making process.  Rather, what I uncovered were moments when my parents and I collaborated to steer his educational development from preschool through to the AP courses he took in high school.  Interactions with teachers, negotiations with school administrators, and imparting our expectations and hopes for my nephew around the kitchen table had been carefully orchestrated and deliberated among the three of us.  Our focus increased in intensity after we enrolled him in a summer college preparation program at my home institution before his senior year in high school.  While he stayed with me, we talked through the college admissions process and, in the fall, scheduled weekly meetings to talk about his applications and scholarship forms.  At the stroke of midnight on New Year’s Eve we submitted his federal financial aid application, knowing that this was critical structural opportunity for someone who qualified as an independent student.  My parents and I collectively held our breath with anticipation and a touch of sadness.  My nephew decided to move across the country to the university where I work.  His choice, although seemingly made independent of his family, was an outcome based on a series of choices that my parents and I had made and through which he (re)negotiated to achieve his (and our) goal of attending college (Martinez, 2013).  His college choice was actually our college choice.

As I observe my nephew’s college experience unfolding, I return to this moment when our family’s hard work and effort, our prayers and aspirations culminated in this one decision—part of which was made by him, by us, and for us by those who do not look like us or share the same experience as us.  Choices are being made, but with little regard for families and communities.  I am troubled by college choice models that offer logical and linear processes within nested contexts that do not accurately reflect what happened and is happening in our lived experience as a family connected across culture, faith, and love.  College choice models do not reflect the systemic and symbolic violence within educational institutions along the P-20 pipeline that is occurring against Communities of Color, low-income communities, and those who are most marginalized.  How can college truly be a choice for these (my) communities, if there are significant academic preparedness and achievement gaps that make the pathway to college, at best, an uncertain endeavor?  Can choosing among colleges (if even a possibility for some) truly be a choice when institutions are not culturally engaged or responsive to the needs of Communities of Color?

I argue that what is missing from our research on college choice is that we do not draw attention to the extent to which social and institutional structures narrow or widen the pathway to college and resulting choice(s) based on prescribed notions of merit, need, and fit.  As institutional agents, we do not necessarily consider how collectivist orientations operate within and among immediate and extended kin who bridge the worlds of academe, community, and culture so that the best decisions can be made with the full support of family and community.  College choice models lead us to believe that there is individual choice, without interrogation of the sorting mechanisms and institutional policies and practices that result in predestined choices.  Choices have already been determined by the values of admissions counselors, by bureaucracies that make it difficult for first-generation students to navigate, and by state and national policies that preclude some from making any reasonable and logical choice.  Yet, we still believe that these choices are our own.

College choice models in their present form do not reflect the aspirational and familial forms of capital that my family brought to the kitchen table every day of my nephew’s young life and over the phone each night in those final moments of high school when he and I reviewed essays and searched college websites.  His final decision was a communal choice, an amassing of all of our knowledge from lived experience and formal education to offer him choices that he would then get to consider and name for himself.  Based on my lived experience as a scholar, daughter, and aunt, I call for a different way of thinking about college choice, which is little more than a “cruel fiction” when considering the lived experiences of students of color and low-income students (Corbett, 2007, p. 30).  We need to conceptualize a new, culturally relevant model that looks less at choice as if this is a freedom and more at how bounded choices are forced upon students through their secondary schooling that may not even lead to college and beyond.  We must interrogate how choices are siphoned off by the very stratified system that purports that students would actually make a choice about a) going to college and b) choosing among many schools with little regard for the economic and emotional impact that leaving one’s home can have on both the individual and the community.  We must hold our institutions and ourselves as institutional agents accountable to not just make space for the marginalized but to evaluate the imposition of values that privilege some and marginalize others, that theorize choice and persistence, that support some on their educational journeys and shut others out.

When I reflect on the circumstances that brought me and my family to this point and when I consider my role in supporting my nephew’s pathway to college, I realize that my college-educated background was not just a factor to be added into the equation.  Along with my family, I helped to construct the pathways that my nephew now follows.  As a family, we offered guidance and reflection, and drew upon our community, familial, and ancestral resources to guide him on his path.  His choice was our choice.  His success will be our success.


References

Alvarez, C. L.  (2010).  Familial negotiation of the Latina college choice process: An   exploration of how parents and their daughters obtain and utilize information to navigate the process.  Enrollment Management Journal, 4(4), 57-80.

Auerbach, S.  (2006).  “If the student is good, let him fly”: Moral support for college among
Latino immigrant parents.  Journal of Latinos and Education, 5(4), 275-292.

Ceja, M.  (2004).  Chicana college aspirations and the role of parents: Developing educational
resiliency.  Journal of Hispanic Higher Education, 3(4), 338-362.

Corbett, M. J.  (2007).  Learning to leave: The irony of schooling in a coastal community.
Halifax: Fernwood Publishers.

Espino, M. M.  (2007, November).  Working in the field: Different perspectives on Mexican
parental involvement and college aspirations.  Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Association for the Study of Higher Education: Louisville.

Espino, M. M.  (2014).  Exploring the role of community cultural wealth in graduate school
access and persistence for Mexican American Ph.D.s.  American Journal of Education, 120(4), 545-575.

Martinez, M. A.  (2013).  (Re)considering the role familismo plays in Latina/o high school students’ college choice.  The High School Journal, 97(1), 21-40.

Valdes, G.  (1996).  Con respeto: Bridging the distances between culturally diverse families and
schools.  New York: Teachers College Press.

Yosso, T. J.  (2005).  Whose culture has capital? A CRT discussion of community cultural wealth.  Race Ethnicity and Education, 8(1), 69-91.

Yosso, T. J.  (2006).  Critical race counterstories along the Chicana/Chicano educational pipeline.  New York: Routledge.

Thursday, January 8, 2015

Difficult times require difficult conversations

by Stephanie Waterman, Associate Professor at the University of Rochester

Don’t shoot

On my way to teach class on November 11, 2014, I passed a group of students protesting the grand jury’s decision not to indict the officer who shot and killed Michael Brown on August 9, 2014, in Ferguson, Missouri. I was concerned for the students’ safety on a wet, very dark, and cold evening. I went to class with worry.

Tuesday nights last fall semester I taught College Access and (In)equity for graduate students in our higher education program. This class was a mix of master’s and doctoral students, with one teaching and curriculum doctoral student. On this night, I devoted the entire class time to discuss “Ferguson.” I felt the class would need to process the grand jury’s decision and its implications. Students were troubled, the room somber. As we all work with college students, and higher education administration and staff, I felt it absolutely necessary to discuss what happened. We cannot ignore what’s happening outside the ivory tower. To do so ignores populations of students and communities that most of our institutions claim to support. Our higher education students work with the college population who were outside protesting. Their students will have questions; they may want to process with us. Their colleagues in offices such as residence life, Greek life, and in academic support may also want to process. I felt it would have been a disservice not to address the issues. If our mission is social justice, equality, and other high moral values, then we absolutely have to address issues of race and injustice.

Over the course of the semester in this class we discussed communities like Ferguson with regard to educational access, resources, and college attendance. We viewed a video produced by Rochester City School District students that depicts a community very similar to that described in And Still We Rise: The Trials and Triumphs of Twelve Gifted Inner-City Students, a distressed community near Los Angeles. These very similar communities are thousands of miles apart, yet, one is in the neighborhood of our institution. What happened in Ferguson very much impacts college access.

I took the theory-as-tool approach as a framework for our discussion. To prepare for our discussion I constructed a PowerPoint to introduce Critical Race Theory (Tate, 1997), and the concepts of privilege and power by Allan Johnson (2005).  I also introduced the intentional stereotyping and image management of African Americans as noted in the film, Ethnic Notions. As conveyed in the film after emancipation when freed Blacks began to compete for jobs, Black Face, Vaudeville, and comics were ways to enforce stereotypes to prevent integration into communities and the economy. Shown as feeble or dangerous, these images infused stereotypes into the common knowledge of society. We then explored websites that provided background information. For example, the Mapping Decline website (mappingdecline.lib.uiowa.edu/map), school district data, and social disparity maps (see www.vox.com). Racial issues are complex; they do not happen overnight and are connected with troubling policies that encouraged White flight. In addition, I shared counterstories of Native American men who are no longer with us because they were “killed while brown.” I shared the Missing or Murdered Indigenous Women website (www.itstartswithus-mmiw.com/background). These counterstories were not shared to compete for which group suffers the most, but to underscore the endemic racism in the United States that affects all of us.

In the 1990s there was a tense political situation in New York State over Native American land claims. A vigilante group had formed who expressed an intent to burn down the homes of Oneidas. If someone was going to join the vigilante group, they were unlikely to first ask which homes were Oneida homes. I have had many a Black male student (professional, graduate student, or both) tell me they were stopped “while driving Black” to and from my class. Or stopped in the library when they were not professionally dressed. Or both Black men and women asked for help in the cafeteria because non-Black students thought they were cafeteria workers and not students. When stereotypes frame action, credentials and details (like race) are ignored.

The conversation on November 11th was not easy; it should not have been—it was absolutely necessary and necessary to discuss for however long it took. The point was not to determine who was right or wrong, who-said-what-and-why, but to use information and tools to help us process, to use theory to help that process, and to model and practice discussing a timely and difficult topic. Students commented that we have issues because we do not talk about race, and that in a class earlier in the evening the jury’s decision was not discussed. They termed it the “elephant in the room.”

I can’t breathe

On December 3, 2014, a decision was made not to indict the officer who killed Eric Gardner.

We devote time and resources to issues that matter, to issues that we value. When these issues are not discussed in the classroom messages are conveyed that certain topics—and the people connected to those topics—are not valued. As a faculty of color it is not my sole responsibility to address issues of race. Did I do a good job with our discussion on November 11th? I don’t really know. All I know is that I had to, because it matters.

Black lives matter
Oppressed lives matter
All lives matter


References:
Corwin, M.  (2001). And still we rise: The trials and triumphs of twelve gifted inner-city students.  New York, NY: Harper Collins Publishers.

Johnson, A. G. (2005). Privilege, power, and difference (2nd ed.). New York, NY: McGraw Hill.

Riggs, M. (Director) (1987). Ethnic notions. Berkeley, CA: California Newsreel.

Tate IV, W. F. (1997).  Critical race theory and education: History, theory, and implications. Review of Research in Education, 22, 195-247.

Monday, December 8, 2014

Navigating Diversity Efforts in STEM through an Equity-Oriented Framework

by Christopher B. Newman, Assistant Professor at University of San Diego 

As a scholar who focuses a majority of my research on outcomes, inequities, and experiences of students of color in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics fields, I have often rationalized the importance of my scholarship with the argument that expanding the STEM pathways to a racially diverse citizenry will inevitable contribute to maintaining U.S. global competitiveness because diverse perspectives contribute to scientific and technological innovations. Concurrently, I have argued the increased diversity in STEM was also a national imperative rooted in historical and systemic inequities. Stated simply, African Americans and other people of color have been systematically diverted from high skilled and high wage labor markets through policy, rhetoric, sabotage, influence, and coercion (see for example Fouché, 2003; James; 1989; Slaton, 2010; Wharton, 1992). These structural barriers have contributed to the persisting gaps in the educational and labor market outcomes for people of color in the United States. Therefore, I assert the intentional actions to obstruct the educational attainment, labor market prospects, and entrepreneurial success of people of color in STEM fields can only be overcome with intentional and sustained efforts of corporations, educational institutions, federal and state policies, and other non-governmental entities.

The recently published book “Falling Behind? Boom, Bust & the Global Race for Scientific Talent” by Michael S. Teitelbaum grabbed headlines with the proclamation that the rationale put forward by corporations, legislators, and the scientific community over the past decade regarding the United States’ waning global competitiveness in STEM was based upon an uncritical analysis of data and trends. One example of how Teitelbaum (2014) scrutinizes the arguments for the decrease in global dominance is by arguing the statistical data on degree completion may be comparing “apples to oranges” as some countries report degrees and certificates in technical areas that would likely not be counted the same way in the United States. Other points of concern focus on the alleged intentional exaggeration by corporations in citing a limited labor force in STEM fields in order to pressure the federal government to issue H1-B visas. Teitelbaum alleges that corporations are pushing for these visas in order to recruit lower wageworkers from aboard. Additionally, Teitelbaum indentifies a cyclical pattern of waxing and waning interest in supporting STEM fields with immense financial resources pumped into STEM fields through federal research grants and other appropriations. This influx of funding increases the production of degrees in STEM, which saturates the market with a well qualified talent pool. Consequently, job opportunities are limited in the field and citizens begin to find other areas for employment prospects. This decrease in enthusiasm for STEM eventually leads to “shortages” and the cycle begins again. Ultimately, Tietelbaum calls for an objective assessment committee, among other things, to evaluate claims of career trends and shortages in STEM fields.

With serious concern over the validity of the global competitiveness argument, I fear the equity rationale is less well received given the prevalent notions of “meritocracy” that have stunted considerable progress (Baez, 2006; Killgore, 2009; Liu, 2010). Nine states (CA, WA, FL, MI, CO, NE, AZ, NH, OK) have legislated Anti-Affirmative Action policies and when cases are heard before the United States Supreme Court it seems the justification for Affirmative Action policies are more narrowly tailored. The movement towards a meritocratic system has made it increasingly difficult in public higher education institutions to support race-based initiatives designed to work against systemic impediments. It should be noted that some private institutions are feeling the pressure and/or stigma from wealthy alumni donors discontinue race-based initiatives for fear of devaluing institutional prestige. In this climate, I often wonder how students of color from urban school districts are supposed to compete for the coveted seats in higher education institutions when their schools are more likely to be considerably lower resourced than their suburban White counterparts? Moreover, what is the responsibility of higher education institutions? Should colleges and universities sit passively by with the expectation that the most meritorious applicants will rise to the top?

In my research, I have paid particular attention to public research universities with records of success in graduating African Americans with degrees in engineering and computer science. After conducting a multiple case study of two campuses (one in the Midwest and one in the Southeast), I found these institutions took an active role in engaging with communities of color through summer science camps for elementary and high school students and through pre-college outreach programs during the academic year.  What I found most striking was the institutional commitment to multiculturalism and racial diversity. Academic clubs with students from all different racial backgrounds participated in outreach efforts, faculty members provided access to their research laboratories to high school students, and the college of engineering also sponsored the various summer camps. These activities created an “equity-oriented” campus culture in STEM fields (Jayakumar & Museus, 2012). Through intentional and sustained action for over 20 years at the Midwestern campus the outcomes of such efforts garnered an estimated 50% undergraduate enrollment yield rate for pre-college outreach participants from the African American Community. The Dean at the college of engineering and other faculty and administrators I interviewed felt these outreach endeavors were an investment in the future of their institution.

Future research needs to move beyond blaming the student and look to higher education institutions’ role in the learning environment created. Too often research focuses on individual attributes of students, which in many ways may take a meritocratic framework with the assumption that the individual is solely responsible for their educational outcomes. Estela Bensimon, Professor of Higher Education and Co-Director of the Center for Urban Education at the University of Southern California, in her work on the equity scorecard recognizes the complexity of inequities and guides leaders to see racial achievement gaps as a problem of practice. This approach emphasizes what institutions are doing to contribute to or hinder the success of students of color. Moving forward, more research on students of color in STEM should include in the analyses institutional level support structures that may contribute to students’ successes and challenges.


References
Baez, B. (2006). Merit and difference. Teachers College Record, 108(6), 996-1016.

Fouché, R. (2003). Black inventors in the age of segregation: Granville T. Woods, Lewis
H. Latimer & Shelby J. Davidson. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.

James, P. P. (1989). The real McCoy: African-American invention and innovation,
1619-1930. Washington, D. C.: Smithsonian Institution Press.

Jayakumar, U. M., & Museus, S. D. (2012). Mapping the intersection of campus cultures and equitable outcomes among racially diverse student populations. In S. D. Museus & U. M. Jayakumar (Eds.) Creating campus cultures: Fostering success among racially diverse student populations. New York: Routledge.

Killgore, L. (2009). Merit and competition in selective college admissions. The Review of Higher Education, 32(4), 469-488.

Liu, A. (2011). Unraveling the myth of meritocracy within the context of US higher education. The International Journal of Higher Education Research, 62(4), 383-397.

Slaton, A. E. (2010). Race, rigor, and selectivity in U.S. engineering: The history of an occupational color line. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Teitelbaum, M. S. (2014). Falling behind? Boom, bust & the global race for scientific talent. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Wharton, D. E. (1992). A struggle worthy of note: The engineering and technological education of Black Americans. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.



Tuesday, November 11, 2014

AERA Division J Official Statement On the Recent Deaths of Forty-Three College Students from Ayotzinapa’s Normal School in Guerrero, Mexico

Student activism has a long legacy of forging social change across the Americas. Like many other noted episodes in this history of activism, college students in Ayotzinapa’s Normal School recently traveled to Chilpancigo, Mexico—capital of the Mexican state of Guerrero—to peacefully protest the increasing university fees and imposed governmental reforms. Forty-three college students from Ayotzinapa’s Normal School formed part of a larger national campaign that sought to commemorate the many college students who were killed by Mexican national forces in 1968. Ironically, rather than having their protests heard, local and state authorities responded with violence, military retaliation, and blatant excessive force. Not only did the local government trample their rights to protest but they also violated their human rights, resulting in the immediate death of six and the disappearance of forty-three (who were all recently confirmed deceased).

The retaliation from the Mexican government sent a message that social activism and mobilization will not be tolerated. As educators, we have an obligation to speak out against injustices where student rights are being violated in such an inhumane manner. We are all global citizens and cannot pretend to ignore the devastation that our fellow students have endured. We should not sit idly when these students acted courageously in exercising their right to peacefully protest and have their voices heard. These young men and women were bravely speaking out against injustice, standing up for a better future for their respective communities, and exercising their right to peacefully assemble. Their deaths should not have a chilling effect on those young and old among us who demand greater accountability from our public officials and our respective governments.
May their souls rest in peace, and may their spirit of social activism live on as a solemn reminder and a renewed legacy to future generations of college student activists. 

If you would like to act, please see the following link.  

Friday, November 7, 2014

How are we preparing graduate students to do educational research focused on broader systems perspectives?

by Lucy A. LePeau, Assistant Professor of Higher Education and Student Affairs at Indiana University Bloomington 

Last November, AERA Division J Vice President Dr. Adrianna Kezar started a dialogue about “thinking about needed research.” As a pre-tenure scholar, I was encouraged reading her post and subsequent posts from Drs. Gildersleeve and Museus calling on researchers to cultivate the intersections in their research and scholarship to make systemic change. Dr. Cox and Dr. Hart also drew attention to the diminishing conference proposals for AERA Division J section Faculty, Curriculum, and Teaching. They all pointed to the abundance of important research focused on students from developmental and outcomes oriented outcomes. Yet, I found myself asking two resounding questions after reading their posts: (1) How do we as educational researchers need to innovate in teaching and socializing graduate students in order to design future research to meet these pressing objectives? and (2) What would graduate education in higher education and related programs (e.g. educational policy and leadership, higher education and student affairs, organizational change) look like if faculty designed aspects of the curriculum as coalition-building movements?

In higher education, graduate students are engaged in coursework that often bifurcates issues in higher education at individual or organizational levels. We need our students to develop deep analytic skills to ground their approaches to scholarly inquiry; depth in foundational content and methodological rigor is important. However, Dr. Gildersleeve called on scholars to use strategies when developing a research agenda that included: looking at policy concerns related to a population of interest, identifying organizational complexities related to the issue, and looking at existing data/implications to address findings that one cannot conclude from individual level data. Faculty, therefore, might employ similar tactics when engaging our students in developing research agendas from systems perspectives. I offer three suggestions for continuing this line of thinking and discussion.

Challenging Scholarly Isolation Within the Classroom:
How might a class be designed to cultivate an intersection? Within undergraduate education, there is a push for interdisciplinary learning in the classroom. Some problem-based learning includes faculty members who approach a topic from more than one discipline co-teach particular classes. I suggest that more classes in higher education break down silos to link across classes for students. Faculty members are trained to develop expertise in particular scholarly domains. For example, some educational researchers study students at the individual level whereas others focus on policy implications. Rather than looking to the student to synthesize and integrate their learning across domains when taking comprehensive exams or formulating dissertation topics, what if a course was taught by two faculty members who maintained their passion and area of emphasis from a particular domain but worked with students to make connections among individual, organizational, and policy levels? Practically speaking, I acknowledge limitations to this idea due to factors such as faculty members needing to demonstrate their teaching design through course evaluations and scheduling challenges due to efficiently putting together semester course loads for faculty. However, I wonder how educational researchers might share how they challenge scholarly isolation in the classroom beyond inviting guest speakers or guest tweeting with students.

Promoting More Opportunities for Learning by Doing:
Some of my formative research experiences occurred with mentors in graduate school who invited me to research with them. It is common practice for graduate students to assume research assistantships and/or volunteer for research teams as part of their education. How are we as educational researchers sharing pedagogy for conducting research that tries to take a systems perspective? I am currently working on a duoethnographic study with a doctoral student, J.T. Snipes, who participated on a research team with me. We are both chronicling the learning that occurred in this experience from our individual and shared perspectives. The act of researching our shared process is challenging me to integrate my teaching and research agenda in a different way and for J.T. to learn more about how he sees himself as a scholar.

Including Graduate Students in Coalition Building:
Dr. Museus outlined a thoughtful example of his own work with the Asian American and Pacific Islander Research Coalition (ARC) as a venue for young scholars to contribute to scholarship focused on AAPI students and communities. How are we developing and reporting about coalition-building within graduate curriculum? One of my colleagues Dr. Danielle DeSawal is serving on the ACPA Presidential Task Force on Digital Technology in Student Affairs. She’s teaching a social media and advising course where students are collecting data for a research project and sharing those results with the digital task force. Therefore, an intentional connection is built between a research agenda connecting scholarship and practice. There are examples of this type of work occurring in higher education. How might scholars strategically collect information about these projects and then work with administrators, policy-makers, and students to translate the ideas into exemplar practices? A coalition is ideal because voices from different sectors invested in addressing pressing issues in higher education are able to discuss whether or not research findings have staying power for policy and practice.

I recognize that there are multiple innovations occurring in graduate education in higher education. I merely alluded to a few examples. It is important that we share those narratives at research conferences like AERA! These connections educational researchers make between teaching and research can propel systems approaches to scholarship.

Tuesday, October 7, 2014

Choosing a career path post-PhD: What do you value?

by Kimberly A. Griffin, Associate Professor at the University of Maryland

This semester, I am teaching my program’s professional seminar for new doctoral students. In addition to introducing these students to a broad survey of the “hot topics” and major areas of study in student affairs and higher education, I’m mindful of the importance of their development as students, researchers, and well-rounded scholars.  But I wonder whether this course, or the others in our curriculum for that matter, really create opportunities for them to think about what and how they’d like to contribute to our field in their own careers.  When do graduate students, in our field and beyond, really have structured opportunities to critically reflect on who they would like to be and what they would like to do?  How do we go beyond panels that present career options and information about various professions to help students make good choices about the next steps they would like to take post-PhD?

For many, career development in the context of a PhD program means training to enter the academy as a faculty member.  However, I have been reading a lot these days about how hard it is for PhDs to get a tenure line faculty job given the current market, increase in the number of adjunct positions, and tight institutional budgets.  In the 1980s, it was a bit easier for PhDs interested in academia to find faculty positions; however, the percentage of graduates in academic positions has declined over time.  In our own field, there are only so many higher education and student affairs graduate programs, and the number of PhDs produced far exceeds the number of available faculty positions posted in a given year.  Schillebeeckx, Maricque, and Lewis highlight the rapid increase in the number of doctorates awarded each year in science and engineering, which is roughly 12 times greater than the number of new faculty positions created.  At the March 2014 annual meeting of the American Historical Association, multiple panels encouraged conversation about the need for a more “malleable PhD” given the imbalance between the number of historians and available faculty positions.

Career development that focuses on academic careers may be inappropriate for another reason: students are expressing less interest in faculty work.  While reports suggest that there are still far more qualified applicants than positions available on most college and university campuses, there is increased attention being focused on the number of graduate students who find academic life unappealing are exploring “alternative” careers, sometimes fairly unrelated to their scholarly training.  While this may not initially appear to be problematic given the lack of available faculty positions, these trends raise critical questions about student career decision-making and the nature of graduate training.  If graduate education has been critiqued for its shortcomings in preparing students for academic careers, what kind of preparation, guidance, and support is being offered for work in other fields, which may in fact be more the norm than “alternative”?

Based on my recent work, the answer would be “not much.” Over the past few years, my research has focused on the career development in graduate and postdoctoral training. I have been working in collaboration with Dr. Kenneth Gibbs Jr on a project that examines patterns of career decision-making for a diverse group of doctoral recipients.  We entered the project with a simple question: What factors and forces throughout their training influence how PhDs make decisions about their careers?

Our findings have been surprising, and I know that I have learned a great deal about graduate training, and how we can do a better job of supporting students as they consider their career options.  As we have analyzed the narratives we have collected through focus groups and over 60 individual interviews, we have begun to realize the importance of values in career decision-making and interest.  Values represented what mattered most to our participants; what makes someone passionate about their work and represented the kinds of contributions they wanted to make. We reported that it was ultimately a person’s professional values, not the number of publications someone had, time to degree, or whether or not they had a good mentor, that ultimately determined whether or not they wanted to be professors.

Some participants had wonderful mentors and strong publication records, but felt academia did not allow them to do research that was relevant to people’s lives in a direct enough way or allowed them to make enough of a difference.  Individuals who placed more value on applied research and making immediate change were more likely to express low levels of interest in the academy.  Conversely, some had difficult experiences with mentors and professors and pretty challenging training experiences overall.  However, if they valued the mentoring and training of students in a more inclusive way or felt like being a professor was the only way for them to engage in academic discovery with autonomy and freedom, academia was still their preference.  We do not interpret this to mean that mentoring and climate issues do not matter in terms of retention and the quality of students’ training experiences; they matter a great deal.  However, when it came to articulating career interests and commitments, values appeared to hold great importance.    

This all may seem very simple, but this work has led me to some broader questions about whether and how graduate students think about their career development.  Some spend a lot of time pursuing what they think is the “right” career – the one that is the most popular or lucrative.  Or perhaps the one that will attract the most attention, provide the best opportunity for life-work balance, or will make their parents or mentors proud.  Even more troubling, our research suggests there are many students who rarely have structured opportunities to think about what they value in relation to their work lives and careers at all.  They usually come to the end of their training with more knowledge about the various career options available, but no greater level of clarity in what they would actually like to do.   Therefore, it seems very important that we begin to think not only about what careers students would like to have when they graduate from their doctoral programs and how to apply for those positions, but what they value.

Students can start the process of figuring out what they value by asking themselves some key questions:
1) At the end of your career, what would you ideally have liked to have contributed?
2) What work stimulates you, and what could you do without?
3) In what environments do you work best (structured, flexible, in an office, at home)?
4) How much would you like to engage with students, and in what capacity?
5) What stages of the research and writing process do you enjoy, and what parts present significant challenges for you?

Once students are more clear on their values and interests in a general sense, the process can shift to determining which careers would be the best fit.  Career development strategies often focus on panels and workshops which present a variety of fields and career options; however, faculty, administrators, and institutional leaders must also think differently about what this kind of programming can and should look like.  For example, Fatimah Williams Castro insists that institutions, faculty, and students must take a more active role in learning about non-academic careers, the skills they require, what is needed to make a smooth transition into a workplace distinct from academe, and what networks can be of most use to them in that process.   Further, while it is certainly true that there are career options that are more viable for some fields than others, the work of helping students make meaning of their career interests and values is a responsibility that can be shared across departments, colleges, and institutions more generally.  Structured opportunities for students to engage in this work with support and guidance may create new means for students to develop interests into career goals that reflect their strengths and values.

A PhD offers preparation for careers far beyond academia, and it is important to have well trained scholars who have the ability to understand problems, think critically, conduct research, and generate strategies and solutions.  Yet, how often do we, as a field, intentionally train students to enter the field of their choice and be successful? As higher education researchers, leaders, and policymakers, it is important for members of Division J to understand these trends, examining and addressing them with both solid strategies and scholarship.

Monday, September 8, 2014

How Do We Know When Educational Research Matters?

by Amelia Marcetti Topper, doctoral candidate in Arizona State University’s Education Policy and Evaluation program; Adai Tefera, Fulton Research Specialist for Arizona State University’s edXchange initiative; and, Gustavo E. Fischman, professor in Arizona State University’s Mary Lou Fulton Teachers College and director of the edXchange initiative. 

Unless you spent this spring sequestered in your office fervidly transforming your research results into acceptable scholarly languages on the off chance they will be published in some High Impact Factor journal, you are probably quite familiar with the academic debate following Nicholas Kristof’s lamentation over the state of the (university) professoriate. According to Kristof, and unfortunately many people both inside and outside academe’s Ivory Tower, academics have been accused of disconnecting themselves from public life and everyday reality, opting to while away their days in monastic solitude. Their marginalization and irrelevance has somehow both been done to them and is also their fault; academia’s very own Stockholm syndrome driven by the “publish or perish” tenure system and the overspecialization of academic disciplines (or so it goes).

Many scholars, in particular, have taken Kristof to task for his simplistic portrayal of academia as “a kingdom of isolation,” to quote the lyrics of Disney’s latest musical earworm. Commentaries in Inside Higher Ed by Allison Kimmich, Gwendolyn Beetham, and Lee Skallerup Bessette have highlighted the resource challenges institutions face in promoting engagement, the particular challenges that women and other marginalized groups confront in having their voices taken seriously, and the often discounted contribution of adjunct faculty and faculty at less-selective two- and four-year institutions. Likewise, another piece by Laura S. Logan and Stephanie Furrer highlighted the important, overlooked work that faculty do in classrooms with their students, often connecting research and reality in very real and impactful ways – sentiments shared by Carol Emberton in The Chronicle of Higher Education.  These articles, along with further rebuttals by professor/blogger Corey Robin, professor/Washington Post commentator Erik Voeten, and Gustavo Fischman and Adai Tefera’s Teachers College Record commentary, among others, speak to a tension over the role of faculty and universities in society that can be traced back to Aristotle, Plato, and Immanuel Kant.

Along similar lines, Adrianna Kezar’s recent blog post asks us in the higher education research community to consider our relationship to the academic community, and the ways in which we – as researchers, as scholars – serve and support our colleagues and students. We would like to add to her thoughts on this topic the importance of finding new ways to collaborate and communicate with both academics (at all levels and in all disciplines) and non-academics (in all positions of society) alike, which is particularly appropriate as we embark on a new academic year.

Namely, we are suggesting to move this debate about the role of the academic as a public intellectual one step forward, from whether or not institutionally based researchers are engaging in the dissemination and wider discussion of their research to how we can recognize and assess the diverse ways in which research, and other types of knowledge, are being produced and used. As the commentators mentioned above passionately (and persuasively) argue, the approximately 1.5 million tenure and non-tenure track faculty members teaching and researching at the nation’s 4,726 public and private colleges and universities contribute to public life in multiple and varied ways that often go unsung – or, at least, unmeasured by metrics of research quality that are limited to article “importance” (i.e., Journal Impact Factor [JIF]). While we are writing from the perspective of faculty, researchers, and students of education and education policy at the largest public research university in the country, what we propose here is relevant across disciplines and institutional contexts. Namely, we argue that it is not just a question of whether our research is intelligible (although that is extremely important), it is also a question of how research can be better accessed, whom it matters to and why, and how it is being discussed, used, and eventually applied.

Knowledge mobilization (KM) is a term used to describe strategies that seek to connect research, policy, and practice by bringing formal (e.g., empirical research) and informal (e.g., personal experience) knowledge to a broader audience. The irony of tackling our culture of “arcane unintelligibility” with such an academic term is not lost on us. We grant you an eye roll, or two, and invite you to keep reading. For more than 50 years this concept (as it goes by other names in other fields) aims to increase access, impact, and usability of research through multi-dimensional, networked, and interactive approaches that engage a wide range of stakeholders in a open, on-going dialogue (not just an article in leading inter/national newspaper or a TV guest spot). While this description in itself might warrant an exasperated sigh, here are two specific examples of what KM strategies look like in practice:

Accessibility of content. One of the largest barriers to the sharing of research knowledge are the exorbitant article fees required by many scholarly journals. Open access policies, the use of Open Access Repositories, and Open Access journals, such as the journals we work on – Current Issues in Education, Education Review, and Education Policy Analysis Archives – provide free, public access to articles, book reviews, commentaries, and video commentaries. Such approaches offer university-sponsored journals a way to make research more accessible and impactful to the wider public, especially when they have a strong social media presence.

Better assessment of “impact.” Access to content needs to be complemented with more comprehensive ways of determining how research knowledge is used and, optimistically, to what extent it makes a difference in how people understand and navigate the world. In the humanities and social sciences, scholarly “impact” has traditionally been narrowly interpreted through bibliometrics – e.g., citation counts and (now) article downloads. While the limitations of using number of cites as an exclusive measure of impact are well known, researchers often seen social media outlets (e.g., Facebook, Twitter, YouTube) as a virtual popularity contest instead of alternative and valid ways to understand the who and how of research impact. Nevertheless, more and more scholars are using these outlets to reach a wider audience beyond the regular “customers” of research journals in education (for Kristof, these would be the very same professors who only see the light of day while in transport to their next obscure academic conference). Altmetrics are one strategy for obtaining a firmer, and (we argue) fairer, understanding of the impact of educational research, as explained by Juan Pablo Alperin: “Altmetrics are captured from the Web (i.e., social media, blogs, Wikipedia), and thus are (somewhat) more democratic – one reader, one vote. More precisely: one reader, several potential votes. Unlike citations, which can only be counted if the citing document is in a select group of journals, altmetrics are counted regardless of where in the world they are originated, with one important consequence: they open the possibility of tracking impact in new segments, both within and beyond the academy.”

We believe that KM strategies, such as the ones that we mention in this article, as well as others, are a viable, substantial improvement and complement to the hierarchical, unimodal model traditionally used to communicate research findings. Researchers at Arizona State University’s new edXchange initiative, for which we also contribute to, are trying to flatten the world of educational research dissemination and use by exploring different ways to embrace KM strategies. edXchange’s goal of mobilizing research knowledge for the common good requires making educational research more accessible by fostering exchanges (e.g., dialogues, visits, consultations, and interactions) between scholars, educators, policymakers, journalists, social entrepreneurs, civic organizations, and concerned individuals to develop solutions that answer today's most pressing educational challenges.

Although the initiative is only a year old, it has already begun the work of engaging in interdisciplinary research-based collaborations to mobilize research relevant knowledge through: a) its Saturday Scholars series, which features TED Talk-style presentations aimed at fostering dialogue with non-specialized audiences around the results of research projects conducted by middle school students, teachers, superintendents and foundation leaders, and scholars during the academic year; b) the creation of the Scholarly Communications Group, to support the journals sponsored by ASU’s Mary Lou Fulton Teachers College and complementing the publication of research articles with video-commentaries, translations, and altmetrics for assessing impact; and, c) with support from the Spencer Foundation, over the next year edXchange will be studying how and when tenure and non-tenure track faculty members at three research universities engage in knowledge mobilization strategies.

As those of use who work in higher education know, faculty members at all types of institutions have been contributing to the intellectual life of the country for more than 400 years through their engagement with students, collaborations and partnerships with their local communities, and the sharing of their research in both academic and nonacademic settings and venues. KM strategies and initiatives, like the ones explored in this commentary, can help us capture and better share with the public the many ways college and university faculty members connect and collaborate with their local, regional, and national communities.

Amelia Marcetti Topper is a doctoral candidate in Arizona State University’s Education Policy and Evaluation program, specializing in higher education. Adai Tefera is a Fulton Research Specialist for Arizona State University’s edXchange initiative, specializing in knowledge mobilization and equity in educational policy. Gustavo E. Fischman is a professor in Arizona State University’s Mary Lou Fulton Teachers College and director of the edXchange initiative. edXchange welcomes the opportunity to collaborate with students, teachers, schools, foundations, and communities on educational research. Share your ideas with us at edxchange@asu.edu, @edxchange.